top of page
Open Book

WELCOME TO THATHISTORYLADY

We are all told, “live your life to the fullest”; I am here to do just that. ThatHistoryLady serves as a vessel to project my passion, for History,  pedagogy and current thinking on curriculum and knowledge.

Read More
Home: Welcome
Home: Blog2
Search

Book review: Drive: The surprising truth about what motivates us

Writer: ThatHistoryLady
ThatHistoryLady
Mar 25, 2019
4 min read

Summary of Drive: The surprising truth about what motivates us, Daniel H. Pink


Soon after I became a Head of Department, I looked closely at the Department's praise policy (and practice) and also the motivation of students, particularly in relation to their GCSE options. Students at my school are asked to choose options of either or both of History or Geography and I was keen that as many as possible would be interested in continuing their study of a subject about which their teachers are all so passionate.


Drive was really helpful in considering both these areas, and also in how self-motivation and resilience translates to enduring progress and attainment - something that Grit is also excellent for. In places Pink draws heavily on the ideas of Dweck's Growth Mindset.







Re-evaluating praise and reward:

Pink's work makes clear is view that traditional “Carrot and Stick” approaches generally do not work and can actually damage attainment, particularly in less routine tasks. Typical ‘if you do this’ praise or sanction can undermine enjoyment, focus, attainment and intrinsic enjoyment of a task. It is better to offer ‘now that’ awards – e.g.  Extrinsic rewards (praise/kind words/letter home) that should be unexpected and offered only after the task is complete. "Predictable praise" was found to be less desirable.


· Non-tangible rewards (e.g. verbal praise – saying thank you or well done where appropriate) are less damaging than tangible rewards (e.g. trophies). Such praise should also be as specific as possible, providing meaningful information about what went well. 


· “Sticks” as punishment (e.g. if you do not do this, this will happen) do not always work and can in effect validate or encourage the negative behaviour the sanction was designed to prevent (e.g. students may see the existence of a predictable punishment as in a sense accommodating their poor behaviour: the punishment did not promote good behaviour, it crowded it out.   This is the one I struggled with the most as it seems to fly in the face of the idea that students benefit from transparent and predictable behaviour policies. However, I recognise this effect in some students already lacking intrinsic motivation. One Year 11 student regularly did not produce homework on time and merely shrugged of getting detentions: the sanction had become routine and predictable. The student appeared to feel that he had ‘paid for’ or countered the misdemeanour by attending the detention. Unless detentions are also met with meaningful discussion between teacher/student, then perhaps there is a risk that the sanction backfires?


· “Carrot and Stick” can still have a role for motivation in more routine tasks that do not require creativity or much independent thought. I still offer (in advance) praise points for the production of flash cards as revision resources for GCSE for instance.  Three steps are advised:

o (i) offer a rationale for why the task is necessary

o (ii) acknowledge that the task may be boring

o (iii) Allow people to complete  the task in their own way – i.e. state the outcome needed but allow complete freedom over how this is reached.  


I have also found that the use of a less 'common' prize appeals to students of all ages - my Sixth Form become incredibly competitive over the offer of a satsuma, for instance!


Different types of motivation:


Pink identifies Type I individuals (fuelled more by intrinsic motivation than by external reward) and Type X individuals (who have a greater focus on extrinsic reward, such as cash, status, and acclaim). Type I is less reward-driven: they take the issue of ‘reward’ off the table so they can focus on doing the task in hand well.  Type I values recognition as a form of constructive feedback, but is not a goal in itself.


Those who exhibit Type I characteristics more frequently almost always outperform Type X in the long term. This is partially because they are not distracted by the pursuit of a reward, which may narrow initiative or put a ceiling on attainment, and also because their behaviour or drive is not finite/limited by the availability of rewards. Type I behaviours can also promote mental and physical wellbeing.


How to encourage Type I behaviour: i.e. how to build drive


DRIVE = AUTONOMOUS PEOPLE WORKING TOWARDS MASTERY, WITH PURPOSE



A toolkit towards Drive – practical things to try:

Homework:

- Give autonomy where possible about how work should be completed: AUTONOMY

- Encourage more than reformulation of information already acquired in lessons: MASTERY

- Ensure students understand WHY the task is set and how it fits into a bigger picture: PURPOSE


DIY reports:

Encourage students to set their own goals and later reflect on their own practice and progress – a comparison with the teacher’s own observations is a good focus for a reflective conversation at a later date. We used ideas from A-Level Mindset to create a 'resilience matrix' for Year 13 to refer to and help with goal setting. - MASTERY


Praise:

- Praise effort and strategy

- Praise in private

- Make praise specific


Encourage students to focus on a bigger picture: PURPOSE

- Where does X event fit into wider History

- How does the study of History help us in the wider world today

- Or even, how will this help you reach your ultimate goal – e.g. a uni/a degree route/ a job – if History is only a stepping stone to some students, then we need to accept that their purpose is elsewhere but that their progress with us is still a valuable (and enjoyable!) part of that


The question of historical relevance and 'fitting into' wider History is one that we keep grappling with as a department - the careful wording of enquiry questions and the sequencing of historical topics is key to this, and is forming part of our ongoing review of the KS3 curriculum in particular.

 
 
 

Comments


Home: Subscribe

CONTACT

London, UK

123-456-7890

Home: Contact
  • twitter

©2019 by ThatHistoryLady. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page