top of page
Open Book

WELCOME TO THATHISTORYLADY

We are all told, “live your life to the fullest”; I am here to do just that. ThatHistoryLady serves as a vessel to project my passion, for History,  pedagogy and current thinking on curriculum and knowledge.

Read More
Home: Welcome
Home: Blog2
Search

Book Review - Make it Stick

Writer: ThatHistoryLady
ThatHistoryLady
Mar 24, 2019
5 min read

Updated: Mar 25, 2019

A review of Make it Stick: The Science of Successful Learning, Brown, Reodiger & McDaniel (2014)



At the beginning of my school's process of GCSE curriculum reform, the perhaps un-glamorous topic of content testing came to the fore. Whilst I loathe the idea that History could be reduced to a Gove-ian list of dates and names, a grasp of factual content is simply crucial in mastery of the subject, and it is not something we should deny or apologise for. Skills become meaningless without core knowledge: students cannot reach convincing judgements or build sustained arguments without detailed, pertinent evidence to support their view. Their work becomes vague, or even borderline fictitious! The use of historical sources is impossible without contextual understanding of the period.The long-term retention of information similarly is crucial within the linear A Level structure, in which students need to retain detailed information for the duration of the whole course.


With these concerns in mind, I read Make It Stick and the summary below shows how the insights provided in that book might best be applied to the History classroom.


Why to Test: One of the most striking findings was the power of active retrieval (testing) to strengthen memory. The art of retrieving learning from memory has two benefits. Firstly it tells the student what they know and don't know, and therefore where to focus for further study. Secondly, recalling what students have learned causes the brain to reconsolidate the memory, which strengthens its connections to what they already know and makes future recall easier.


Application in History: Regular self-quizzing, low stakes quizzing in lessons, formal content tests. We also advise students now to categorise questions on quizzes or terms on key-terms sheets into 'know' and 'don't know' to inform where they should spend their time most profitably.


How to test - effort: The more effortful the retrieval the stronger the benefit. Effortful retrieval was more effective than re-reading: practising retrieval made learning stick far more than re-exposure to the original material.


Application in History: Students should not merely re-read notes. As a Department we have really started to push "active revision" - encouraging students to create and take content tests, to use Q&A flashcards or Quizlet, and anything that requires the retrieval of information rather than just exposure to it. We regularly tell parent that if students spend revision time "just reading" notes, it is unlikely to be very useful.


How to test – repetition: To be most effective retrieval must be repeated again and again.


Application in History: The repeated testing in exams the students undergo particularly in preparation for GCSE (at my school students take a 3 year GCSE course and as a result sit three sets of exams before the real thing) and A Level (Year 13 mock exams should explicitly require coverage of Year 12 content) provides the required repeated retrieval of information that is most beneficial. This could be further developed by more regular content tests as ‘low stakes’ starters.


How to test – with delay: Retrieval practice needs to be spaced out, so that the recall, rather than becoming an exercise in mindless repetition, instead requires some cognitive effort. After an initial test, delaying subsequent retrieval practice is more potent for reinforcing the retention of information than immediate practice, because delayed retrieval practice requires more effort. Repeated retrieval not only makes memories more durable but produces knowledge that can be retrieved more readily. The simple act of spacing out study and practice in instalments and allowing time to elapse in-between, made memory stronger.


Application in History: Cumulative content testing, so that earlier topics are repeated and students expect that they will be called upon to retain information in the longer term.

The repeated testing in exams the students undergo particularly at GCSE and A Level provides the required repeated retrieval of information that is most beneficial.


Complex mastery of information: Studies carried out on medical students suggested that the kind of retrieval practice that is most effective is one that reflects what you'll be doing with the knowledge later on. It's not just what you know, but how you practice what you know, that determines how well the learning serves you later.


Application in History: For our purposes this meant phrasing questions in a more nuanced way, reflecting the questions they may be asked in an exam or considering concepts such as causation or significance. For example:

Rather than asking: When was there social unrest in Elizabethan England? A: 1569/1571

Instead ask: What instance of social upheaval caused Elizabethan government to pass the Poor Laws? A: Rebellion in the north in 1569 / plot to murder Elizabeth was discovered 1571

This added historical meaning to the facts students must recall, rather than revision becoming the dreaded list of names and dates mentioned above. The question itself was educative.


Creating desirable difficulty in the classroom: Research showed that students find quizzing more acceptable when it is predictable and the stakes for any individual quiz is low. Teachers find also quizzing more acceptable when it is simple and quick. It is more profitable in the long term to make quizzing and practice exercises count towards a final grade even if for very low stakes. Students in classes where practice exercises carried consequences for the course grade learned better than those in classes where the exercises were the same but carried no consequences.


Application in History:

Within my department we have been careful to set fact testing well in advance and be clear about what will be tested. On occasion we also reveal the questions in advance (e.g. giving 40 possible questions that students should know/be able to locate the answers to and then test 20 of them). We have also taken the step of including formal content testing as part a student's termly grade. It is included in the school's data system as an indication of progress in the same way that 'skills assessments' are.


Know the limits of content testing and follow-up in the right way:

Giving students corrective feedback after tests also keeps them from incorrectly retaining material that they have previously misunderstood. This is important even when students have got all the questions right - thoughtful whole-class feedback with targeted questioning can be very revealing. For instance, in a content test on the causes of poverty in Elizabethan England, the majority of my Year 9 class correctly answered that enclosure was an important cause. However, in focused hands-down follow-up discussion, it was clear that far fewer students really understood what enclosure really was and quite how it led to poverty. This meant in turn they would be less likely to understand the development of vagrancy during Elizabeth's reign, or the harsh response to vagrants. Spending feedback time zooming in on areas of common confusion (which enclosure seems to be!) is well worth the time as it clarifies knowledge on a deeper level, even amongst students who have superficially 'got it' through rote learning.


There is no getting away from it, and neither should there be: "knowing stuff" is crucial for success in History. I am sure that all History professionals (and students?!) relish the deeper understanding that History allows, but you cannot have the latter without the former. Make It Stick provides really workable guidance for making quizzing, testing, retrieval practice, whatever you want to call it, more impactful and less 'painful'!

 
 
 

Comments


Home: Subscribe

CONTACT

London, UK

123-456-7890

Home: Contact
  • twitter

©2019 by ThatHistoryLady. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page